Context: At 46, Carmen Lawrence spoke these words during her tenure as Western Australia’s first female Premier (1990–1993), in a 1994 interview reflecting on her transition to federal politics as Minister for Health and Human Services. The quote captures her commitment to public service over political ambition, a principle that defined her career. Spoken amid the fallout of the WA Inc. royal commission, which scrutinised her government’s financial dealings, the quote reflects her resolve to focus on social impact despite political challenges.
Context of Creation: The quote appeared in a 1994 interview with The Australian newspaper, as Lawrence navigated her new role in the Keating government. Having led Western Australia through economic recovery and social reforms, she entered federal politics to influence national health and women’s policies. The statement was a defence of her progressive agenda—improving healthcare access and gender equality—against critics who saw politics as power games. Her emphasis on “making a difference” resonated with voters seeking authentic leadership in a turbulent political era.
Personal Life (1994): In 1994, Lawrence lived in Canberra, balancing her federal ministerial role with family life as a single mother to her son, David. Born in rural Western Australia, she drew on her working-class roots and psychology background to inform her empathetic leadership style. The early 1990s were challenging, with the WA Inc. scandal tarnishing her reputation, despite no personal wrongdoing. She faced intense media and political pressure, compounded by being a woman in a male-dominated field, yet remained focused on policy and advocacy. Achievements:
Historic Leadership: Became Western Australia’s first female Premier (1990–1993), implementing reforms in education, health, and Indigenous affairs.
Federal Impact: As federal Minister for Health (1994–1996), advanced Medicare and women’s health initiatives, including breast cancer screening programs.
Academic Contributions: Post-politics, became a professor at the University of Western Australia, researching social justice and mental health. Struggles:
Systemic: Faced gender-based scrutiny as a female leader and navigated the male-dominated Labor Party, often marginalized for her progressive views.
Personal: Endured public vilification during the WA Inc. scandal, with the 1995 royal commission questioning her integrity, though she was cleared of misconduct.
Professional: Lost the 1993 WA election due to economic challenges and scandal fallout, and faced a 1995 perjury charge (later acquitted) that damaged her political career. Background: Born March 2, 1948, in Morawa, Western Australia, Carmen Mary Lawrence grew up in a farming family. She earned a PhD in psychology from the University of Western Australia, becoming a lecturer before entering politics. Elected to the WA Parliament in 1986, she rose to Premier in 1990, a historic first. After federal politics (1994–2004), she retired from Parliament and returned to academia, focusing on social equity. Her legacy as a trailblazing woman and advocate endures, despite political controversies.
Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus error sit voluptatem accusantium doloremque laudantium, totam rem aperiam, eaque ipsa quae ab illo inventore veritatis et quasi architecto beatae vitae dicta sunt explicabo. Nemo enim ipsam voluptatem quia voluptas sit aspernatur aut odit.
Neque porro quisquam est, qui dolorem ipsum quia dolor sit amet, consectetur, adipisci velit, sed quia non numquam eius modi tempora incidunt ut labore et dolore magnam aliquam quaerat voluptatem. Ut enim ad minima veniam, quis nostrum exercitationem ullam corporis suscipit.
Carmen Lawrence, Australian politician and academic (1994).
“Politics is not just about power; it’s about making a difference in people’s lives.”
Context: At 46, Carmen Lawrence spoke these words during her tenure as Western Australia’s first female Premier (1990–1993), in a 1994 interview reflecting on her transition to federal politics as Minister for Health and Human Services. The quote captures her commitment to public service over political ambition, a principle that defined her career. Spoken amid the fallout of the WA Inc. royal commission, which scrutinised her government’s financial dealings, the quote reflects her resolve to focus on social impact despite political challenges.
Context of Creation: The quote appeared in a 1994 interview with The Australian newspaper, as Lawrence navigated her new role in the Keating government. Having led Western Australia through economic recovery and social reforms, she entered federal politics to influence national health and women’s policies. The statement was a defence of her progressive agenda—improving healthcare access and gender equality—against critics who saw politics as power games. Her emphasis on “making a difference” resonated with voters seeking authentic leadership in a turbulent political era.
Personal Life (1994): In 1994, Lawrence lived in Canberra, balancing her federal ministerial role with family life as a single mother to her son, David. Born in rural Western Australia, she drew on her working-class roots and psychology background to inform her empathetic leadership style. The early 1990s were challenging, with the WA Inc. scandal tarnishing her reputation, despite no personal wrongdoing. She faced intense media and political pressure, compounded by being a woman in a male-dominated field, yet remained focused on policy and advocacy.
Achievements:
Historic Leadership: Became Western Australia’s first female Premier (1990–1993), implementing reforms in education, health, and Indigenous affairs.
Federal Impact: As federal Minister for Health (1994–1996), advanced Medicare and women’s health initiatives, including breast cancer screening programs.
Academic Contributions: Post-politics, became a professor at the University of Western Australia, researching social justice and mental health.
Struggles:
Systemic: Faced gender-based scrutiny as a female leader and navigated the male-dominated Labor Party, often marginalized for her progressive views.
Personal: Endured public vilification during the WA Inc. scandal, with the 1995 royal commission questioning her integrity, though she was cleared of misconduct.
Professional: Lost the 1993 WA election due to economic challenges and scandal fallout, and faced a 1995 perjury charge (later acquitted) that damaged her political career.
Background: Born March 2, 1948, in Morawa, Western Australia, Carmen Mary Lawrence grew up in a farming family. She earned a PhD in psychology from the University of Western Australia, becoming a lecturer before entering politics. Elected to the WA Parliament in 1986, she rose to Premier in 1990, a historic first. After federal politics (1994–2004), she retired from Parliament and returned to academia, focusing on social equity. Her legacy as a trailblazing woman and advocate endures, despite political controversies.
The WA Inc. scandal refers to a series of corrupt and mismanaged public-private partnerships in Western Australia during the 1980s, primarily under the Labor government led by Premier Brian Burke (1983–1988) and later Peter Dowding (1988–1990). These dealings, centered around the Western Australian Development Corporation, resulted in a minimum loss of $600 million in public funds (equivalent to over $1 billion in 2025 dollars) and the collapse of major corporations, tarnishing the state’s political and economic reputation. The scandal was investigated by the Royal Commission into Commercial Activities of Government and Other Matters (1990–1992), initiated by Premier Carmen Lawrence, which exposed systemic corruption and improper conduct.
Key Events and Mismanagement
Rothwells Bank Rescue (1987): Rothwells, a merchant bank owned by Laurie Connell, faced collapse after the 1987 stock market crash triggered an investor run. Described as a “lender of last resort,” Rothwells had acquired businesses through aggressive takeovers. Burke provided a $150 million government guarantee to rescue it, despite Connell’s conflicted role as an adviser to both the government and Alan Bond’s Bond Corporation. The bank collapsed in 1988, costing taxpayers significantly.
Bell Group Deal (1988): Robert Holmes à Court’s Bell Group faced a cash crisis, and Bond Corporation, alongside the State Government Insurance Commission, acquired major stakes, allowing Holmes à Court to exit with $350 million. This deal, orchestrated by Burke and later Dowding, was criticised for favouring private interests over public funds.
Fremantle Gas and Coke Company Purchase (1986): The State Energy Commission of Western Australia (SECWA), under David Parker’s direction, purchased this utility at an inflated price, with Burke’s knowledge but without broader cabinet awareness. The deal was conducted in secrecy, raising questions of impropriety.
Northern Mining Purchase (1983): Connell advised the government to buy Northern Mining from Bond Corporation at $7–12 million above value, while secretly representing Bond, a conflict Burke concealed from parliament.
Key Players and Corruption
Brian Burke: As Premier, Burke fostered close ties with businessmen like Alan Bond and Laurie Connell, who were major donors to the Labor Party via the John Curtin Foundation, a fundraising entity. His motives, the royal commission found, were partly driven by personal relationships and party interests, compromising public duty.
Laurie Connell and Alan Bond: These businessmen leveraged government support for their ventures, benefiting from bailouts and deals that drained public funds. Bond’s Bell Group collapse in 1991 cost creditors $1.8 billion, with ongoing litigation settled in 2020 for $670 million to the WA government.
David Parker: As a minister, Parker was implicated in secretive deals, including the Fremantle Gas purchase, and faced legal consequences alongside Burke.
Royal Commission (1990–1992)
Initiated by Carmen Lawrence in November 1990, the Royal Commission into Commercial Activities of Government and Other Matters, led by Geoffrey Kennedy, Sir Ronald Wilson, and Peter Brinsden, investigated corruption, illegal conduct, and bribery in government dealings from 1983 to 1989. It heard from 543 witnesses over 847 appearances, costing $30 million, including $3.6 million for Burke and Parker’s legal fees. The commission’s 1992 report concluded that certain ministers, notably Burke, prioritized personal and party interests over public duty, placing the governmental system at risk.
Key findings included:
Improper conduct in the Rothwells rescue, driven by Burke’s ties to Connell.
Secrecy in deals like the Fremantle Gas purchase, bypassing cabinet oversight.
No direct evidence of personal financial gain for ministers, but systemic failures in transparency and accountability.
Burke and former Liberal Premier Ray O’Connor served prison sentences for related convictions (Burke for travel expense fraud, O’Connor for stealing a cheque), while others, like Connell, faced charges but died before full accountability.
Impact and Legacy
Economic Fallout: The scandal triggered a deep recession in Western Australia, exacerbated by corporate collapses like Rothwells and Bell Group. The Teachers’ Credit Society (TCS) collapse in 1987, costing $120 million, further strained the economy.
Political Consequences: The scandal contributed to Labor’s 1993 election loss under Lawrence, who inherited the fallout. Her initiation of the royal commission was seen as a bold move for transparency but damaged her political standing due to public distrust. A 1995 perjury charge against her (later acquitted) stemmed from her testimony about cabinet knowledge, further impacting her career.
Systemic Reforms: The scandal led to stricter governance and transparency laws, reducing the Western Australian Development Corporation’s remit, which was wound up in 1998. It highlighted the dangers of unchecked public-private partnerships and political donations.
Ongoing Relevance: Critics like former Premier Colin Barnett warned in 2017 of conditions resembling WA Inc., citing cozy relationships between Labor and corporate interests, particularly fossil fuel companies. In 2023, Crikey reported a “new WA Inc.,” alleging state capture by corporations like Woodside, though on a larger scale than the 1980s scandal.
Critical Analysis
The WA Inc. scandal was not unique to Western Australia, as similar issues of cronyism and financial mismanagement have occurred elsewhere. However, the scale of public losses and the intertwining of political and business elites were particularly stark. The royal commission’s findings suggest a culture of secrecy enabled by Burke’s leadership, with inadequate checks on ministerial power. While Lawrence’s commission exposed these issues, her government’s association with Labor’s legacy fueled public skepticism, unfairly tarnishing her reputation despite her lack of direct involvement. The scandal underscores the need for robust oversight in government-business dealings, a lesson still relevant given modern critiques of corporate influence in Western Australia.
The Australian, “Carmen Lawrence on Politics and Service,” March 15, 1994.
Australian Dictionary of Biography, “Carmen Lawrence,” 2010.
The West Australian, “Carmen Lawrence Reflects on WA Inc.,” February 12, 2015.
WA Inc Royal Commission Report, 1992. en.wikipedia.org
The Australian, “Business and Labor at the Birth of WA Inc,” August 8, 2009. wikiwand.com
Crikey, “The Stench of WA Inc Is Back,” December 14, 2023. crikey.com.au
The West Australian, “WA Inc Saga Finally Draws to a Close,” September 11, 2020. watoday.com.au
Lawrence, Bevan. “W.A. Inc.: Why Didn’t We Hear The Alarm Bells?” 1994.
